014 从无麸质到生酮:营养师眼里的流行饮食神话 A Bite into Nutrition Myths from Gluten-Free to Keto选修课 Universus

014 从无麸质到生酮:营养师眼里的流行饮食神话 A Bite into Nutrition Myths from Gluten-Free to Keto

95分钟 ·
播放数2433
·
评论数21

【聊了什么 The What】

无麸质饮食真的更健康吗?减肥到底该低碳还是低脂?市面上五花八门的保健品,是不是智商税?关于“吃”这件事,我们每天都在做决定,却也时常感到困惑。本期节目,我们请来美国注册营养师张千慧博士,为你一一击破关于流行饮食的常见迷思。

我们将以“无麸质饮食”和“低脂 vs. 低碳之争”为两大案例,回顾营养科学的发展轨迹,探讨其研究范式的局限性,并揭示食品工业的利益冲突如何深刻影响着公共卫生建议。究竟是否存在一套适合所有人的“最佳饮食”?当面对海量的营养信息时,我们该如何建立自己的思辨框架?本期节目将带你“浅尝不止”,从科学与历史的纵深处,重新理解我们与食物的复杂关系。

Is going gluten-free really healthier? When it comes to weight loss, should you cut carbs or fat? And what about all those supplements on the market—are they worth it or just a scam? Eating is something we do every day, yet we’re constantly confused by conflicting information. In this episode, we invite Dr. Jera Zhang, a registered dietitian based in the U.S., to debunk some of the most common myths surrounding popular diets.

Focusing on two major case studies—“the gluten-free diet” and “the low-fat vs. low-carb debate”—we trace the evolution of nutrition science, question the limitations of its research paradigms, and expose how corporate interests in the food industry shape public health recommendations. Is there truly one “optimal” diet for everyone? How do we build our own critical thinking framework amid a flood of nutritional advice? This episode goes beyond surface-level bites, offering a deeper historical and scientific look into our complex relationship with food.

【时间轴 The When】

  • 02:10 从流行饮食审视人与食物的关系。

  • 05:10 详解无麸质饮食:麸质的定义,无麸质饮食的医学起源,谁需要无麸质饮食

  • 26:43 低碳水化合物与低脂饮食的世纪之争

  • 42:55 Q&A:低碳对女性生理期影响,在美国什么情况下可以看营养师,益生菌、保健品(维生素D、鱼油等)

  • 65:12 营养学研究的复杂性和食品工业的强大影响力

  • 02:10 Viewing human-food relationships through the lens of popular diets

  • 05:10 Deep dive into gluten-free diets: What is gluten, the medical origins of gluten-free eating, who really needs it

  • 26:43 The century-long battle between low-carb and low-fat diets

  • 42:55 Q&A: Effects of low-carb diets on menstrual cycles, when to see a dietitian in the U.S., probiotics and supplements (vitamin D, fish oil, etc.)

  • 65:12 The complexity of nutrition research and the powerful influence of the food industry

【我们是谁 The Who】

选修课 Universus 是一档分享和探讨泛文化话题的中文播客,脱胎于2013年创办的纽约文化沙龙。我们力求引发对学科方法和视角的认知和思考,而不仅仅是知识的传递。我们在组织活动的过程中积累了一些经验和人脉,尝试打造成年人的博雅教育,并在播客中拓展这样的探索。我们希望审视和反抗无意识的价值规训与随波逐流。我们希望冷酷地剖析自己的偏见,热忱地拥抱多元视角。我们希望去工具化,真诚地感知、理解、创造自己的生活和复杂的世界。我们追随原初的好奇而非代餐式的猎奇。话题可以轻松,方法力求严肃。在《选修课》里,我们互相映照,唤醒失落的维度。

主讲:

  • 张千惠 Jera Zhang: 美国注册营养师,纽约市立大学亨特学院营养与公共健康系助理教授

选修课 Universus is a Chinese-language podcast created by the same people who founded the New York Chinese Cultural Salon (纽约文化沙龙)in 2013.The past decade of organizing events and talks put us in a position of creating a sort of liberal arts education experience for those who have left school. We strive to go beyond merely transmitting knowledge to reflecting on complex topics using cross-disciplinary perspectives. We strive to resist conformity, to dissect our own biases, and to embrace diverse schools of thought. Our goal is to help professionals resist becoming just a tool of production, and to understand the world around us in earnest. We let our genuine curiosity be our guide. With a light-hearted tone, we approach each topic seriously. We hope that “选修课 Universus” creates a space to explore lost dimensions.

Our guest:Jera Zhang: Registered Dietitian (RD), Assistant Professor in the Department of Nutrition and Public Health at Hunter College, City University of New York

【买咖啡 Please Support Us】如果喜欢这期节目并愿意想要给我们买杯咖啡:

  • 打赏平台:www.patreon.com/universuspod
  • 商务合作邮箱:universuspod@gmail.com

If you like our show and want to support us, please consider the following:

  • 打赏平台: www.patreon.com/universuspod
  • Business Inquiries Email: universuspod@gmail.com
展开Show Notes
Happymommy1
Happymommy1
2025.9.03
谢谢主播及时调整声音。嘉宾说的很真诚,并没有像很多营养师那样忽悠大概念,其实美国这么多年不停有各种营养概念出现,个人感觉和商业利益挂钩的偏多。关于健康饮食,一个小感想,记得去南欧几个国家发现当地饮食并没有特别符合普遍的健康饮食标准,他们吃的高碳,绝对不底油低糖,最无法忍受的是晚上七点半之后才开始晚餐,但的确他们的平均寿命不错,想来想去应该是食材好,菜有菜味儿,肉有肉香,随便一个小摊上的都比美国organic超市的味道好,查了资料才知道欧盟的食品标准比美国高很多。所以嘉宾说的很对,能经常吃到新鲜安全的未加工食材才是王道。
HD629607l
HD629607l
2025.9.17
1:31:39 菠菜,草莓,kale, grapes,和什么?听不清
Nathan_N0N4:猜是peach
Nathan_N0N4:The "Dirty Dozen" list is an annual report by the Environmental Working Group (EWG) that identifies the 12 conventional fruits and vegetables with the highest pesticide residues. The 2025 list includes spinach, strawberries, kale/collard/mustard greens, grapes, peaches, cherries, nectarines, pears, apples, blackberries, blueberries, and potatoes.
Sudaholic
Sudaholic
2025.9.19
感觉主讲老师很紧张
LittleFishBi
LittleFishBi
2025.9.03
34:12 哈哈哈哈哈听完就是想吃啥吃啥呗,反正这些概念都是被市场利用来炒作过来炒作过去。
许可_Sycc
许可_Sycc
2025.9.02
1:16:13 感受到了主讲人的真诚和善意
在野22
在野22
2026.2.03
感觉前面新闻联播式的营养师资历介绍特别扭
木心立里
木心立里
2026.1.10
哈哈感觉嘉宾紧张到喘气困难
zuKiKi_
zuKiKi_
2025.11.27
06:00 请问有ppt可以分享吗(这里讲到一张图,想知道长什么样)
Happymommy1
Happymommy1
2025.9.02
声音特别小,能否调整一下,谢谢
赵智沉
:
紧急更新中!
赵智沉
:
音频更新了!
NFLY
NFLY
2025.10.15
有主讲老师别的公共社交平台账号吗?想去关注!
JoyL_0XvC
JoyL_0XvC
2025.9.02
这期是不是声音很小?
赵智沉
:
紧急更新中!
赵智沉
:
音频更新了!
这个节目听得我喘不上气来
HD999236v
HD999236v
2025.9.03
请问日本排核有必要尽量少吃海鲜么?国内很多人不敢吃,国外很少提这个,主要受到政治宣传影响,但是从科学的角度好像也没法明确给出定论
有点跑题,不过作为公众,如何用逻辑以及知识来分析呢?
来啦
沙发!开听!