本文探讨了“政治正确”(PC)标签在反歧视语言运动中的作用。作者认为,将语言变化建议贴上“PC”标签并非只是一种简单的反对策略,它揭示了一场公开辩论,其结果不仅可能损害所谓的“PC”运动,也可能促进它们。“PC”标签的出现标志着语言建议进入公共领域的一个关键时刻,它不是一种立即的改变,而是一个有待更广泛社会接受或拒绝的待定请求。
为了分析“PC”话语中的语言变化,文章提出了一个五阶段的谴责模型。该模型指出,一个最初中性的表达如何逐渐获得负面含义,最终可能成为禁忌。文章以以色列的“Autist”(自闭症患者)一词为例,展示了该词如何从临床术语发展为隐喻和侮辱,并最终(也许是暂时地)成为一种被禁止的禁忌。“Autist”一词在 2019 年引发了一场重大的“PC”辩论,最终导致该词作为侮辱性用语的消失。
作者认为,“PC”标签的出现及其引发的辩论,在推动语言规范的改变方面发挥着重要作用。当语言建议被贴上“PC”标签时,支持该建议的人会将其视为对其身份和价值观的攻击,这往往会导致反击那些抵制语言建议的人。这种冲突最终会通过更广泛的公众参与得到解决,公众要么改变其语言使用,要么拒绝改变。
This article examines the role of the label "PC" (political correctness) in anti-discriminatory language campaigns. The author argues that labeling suggestions for language change as "PC" is not merely a dismissive tactic of opposition, but rather reveals a public debate, the outcome of which may not only harm so-called "PC" campaigns but also promote them. The emergence of the "PC" label represents a pivotal moment where a linguistic suggestion enters the public sphere—not as an immediate change, but as a pending request that must still be accepted or rejected by broader society.
The article proposes a five-stage condemnation model for analyzing language change in the PC discourse. The model outlines how an initially neutral expression can gradually acquire negative meanings and may eventually become taboo. Using the expression "Autist" in Israeli public discourse as an example, the article demonstrates how this expression developed from a clinical term into a metaphor and an insult, and eventually (and perhaps temporarily) became a prohibited taboo. The use of "Autist" as an insult triggered a major "PC" debate in 2019, ultimately leading to its disappearance as a derogatory term.
The author suggests that the emergence of the "PC" label and the ensuing debate play a significant role in driving changes in language norms. When a linguistic suggestion is labeled "PC," those in favor of the suggestion perceive the label as an attack on their identity and values, which often leads to counterattacks directed at the labelers for their resistance to the linguistic suggestion. This conflict is ultimately resolved through the involvement of the broader public, who either change their use of language or reject the change.
文献来源:Saadon, A. (2024). The discursive role of the label “PC”: Analyzing changes in discriminatory language with the condemnation model. Discourse & Society. doi.org
