087 | 情感价值 & 左撇子女孩:不长嘴的父母,被困住的女儿 Sentimental Value, Left-Handed Girl, and the Family Trauma Plot疲惫娇娃 CyberPink

087 | 情感价值 & 左撇子女孩:不长嘴的父母,被困住的女儿 Sentimental Value, Left-Handed Girl, and the Family Trauma Plot

94分钟 ·
播放数5881
·
评论数30

【一起来读书吧 Bookclub】

《台湾漫游录》线下读书会:8月9日,我们会在纽约中文独立书店Accent Sisters举办《台湾漫游录》线下读书会。故事讲述了1938年日本统治台湾时期,一位年轻的日本女性小说家来到岛上,希望能一路吃穿台湾,在这个过程中她爱上了自己的女性翻译,但却苦于难以克服殖民者与被殖民者之间的鸿沟。这本书今年斩获了国际布克奖,是首部获得这部奖项的华语原著作品。

"Taiwan Travelogue" In-Person Book Club:On August 9th, we'll be hosting an in-person book club for Taiwan Travelogue at Accent Sisters, a Chinese-language independent bookstore in New York. The story follows a young Japanese novelist who travels to Taiwan during the Japanese colonial period in 1938, hoping to eat and dress her way across the island. Along the way, she falls in love with her female translator, but struggles to overcome the gulf between colonizer and colonized. The book won this year's International Booker Prize, making it the first Chinese-language original work to receive the award.

【聊了什么The What】

这期节目,我们和友台新新人类的主播采薇把去年两部大火的关于家庭创伤的电影——《情感价值》和左撇子女孩。一部是台北夜市里五光十色的单亲家庭故事,一部是奥斯陆老宅里安静流淌的父女和解。表面上文化背景毫不相干,但其实在讲同一件事:房子如何变成家族秘密的容器,孩子如何在大人自己都说不清的沉默里,替上一代扛下没有被言说的创伤。

孩童视角的滤镜,是四两拨千斤的巧思,还是对真实伤害的一次美化和逃避?一个从未说出"对不起"的父亲,值得被原谅吗?还是我们能给出的,只是一种不求回报的宽恕?创伤到底是应该被讲述出来,还是有些沉默本该被尊重?

In this episode, we're joined by Caiwei, our friend from Pixel Perfect, to talk about two of last year's buzziest films about family trauma: Sentimental Value and Left-Handed Girl. One is a single-mother story set amid the neon chaos of a Taipei night market; the other is a quiet, slow-burning father-daughter reconciliation unfolding inside an old house in Oslo. On the surface, the cultural backdrops couldn't be more different, but underneath, both films are doing the same thing: turning a house into a vessel for family secrets, and asking how children end up carrying the unspoken trauma of the generation before them, inherited through silences the adults themselves can't put into words.

Is the child's-eye filter a clever, light-touch device, or is it a way of prettifying and dodging real harm? Does a father who never says "I'm sorry" deserve to be forgiven — or is the most we can offer him a kind of grace that asks for nothing in return? And should trauma be spoken aloud at all, or is some silence owed its own respect?

【时间轴 The When】

  • 03:50 - 《左撇子女孩》剧情简介:台北夜市里破碎的三代女性

  • 26:25 - 两片中的孩子:以静 vs Eric,谁在拯救谁

  • 31:30 - 母亲与姐姐角色的"男性意淫"式书写

  • 45:43 - 父亲是"Art Monster":唯一的爱的管道是作品

  • 56:28 - 挪威二战历史、祖母之死与集体沉默

  • 63:16 - Elle Fanning与美国:天真的旁观者,以及一把"骗人"的IKEA椅子

  • 73:29 - Catherine Liu的"创伤文化"理论:好莱坞的同理心剧场

  • 77:14 - 宽恕与原谅的区别:Nora 和 Agnes 的成长弧光

  • 89:15 - 一部关于电影、表演与创伤消费的电影

  • 03:50 - Left-Handed Girl plot rundown: three generations of women coming apart in a Taipei night market

  • 26:25 - The kids in both films: Yijing vs. Eric — who's actually saving whom

  • 31:30 - The mother and older sister as "male-gaze fantasy" — how their characters are written

  • 45:43 - The father as "Art Monster": art as his only channel for love

  • 56:28 - Norway's WWII history, the grandmother's death, and a collective silence

  • 63:16 - Elle Fanning and America: the innocent bystander, plus one very deceptive IKEA chair

  • 73:29 - Catherine Liu's "trauma culture" theory: Hollywood's theater of empathy

  • 77:14 - Grace vs. forgiveness: the arcs of Nora and Agnes

  • 89:15 - A film about filmmaking, performance, and the consumption of trauma

【买咖啡 Please Support Us】

如果喜欢这期节目并愿意想要给我们买杯咖啡:

  • 海外用户:www.patreon.com
  • 海内用户:afdian.com
  • 商务合作邮箱:cyberpinkfm@gmail.com
  • 商务合作微信:CyberPink2022

If you like our show and want to support us, please consider the following:

  • Those Abroad: www.patreon.com
  • Those in China: afdian.com
  • Business Inquiries Email: cyberpinkfm@gmail.com
  • Business Inquiries WeChat: CyberPink2022

Support on Patreon | 爱发电上赞助

展开Show Notes
Cesium-137
Cesium-137
2026.7.27
左撇子女孩很不台湾。就像一个外国人去台湾自由行一趟之后决定要拍台湾夜市而产生的作品。
READMEe:其实就是肖恩贝克的汉化作品
Cesium-137:我觉得肖恩贝克自己的每一部作品都比这个走心太多了。。从主题和对象的选择到拍摄手法
很久没有氛围检查了 很需要
1:27:18 哈哈哈哈”这个电影里真有Elle Fanning”太妙了,在Angelika看的主创Q&A她有来,入场和退场的时候她的保镖立刻敏捷地站出来挡到主创和观众之间,和电影里Gustav在餐厅越过保镖去见她那一幕完美重叠
pp_xyz
pp_xyz
2026.7.27
27:20 小女孩真的超级棒 看着她能原谅全世界了
霏儿
霏儿
4天前
声音好小
Jabulous
Jabulous
9天前
31:49 可能就是对台湾文艺作品的美式想象🥹
我觉得角色是很贴合现实的,东亚这样的家庭,这样的妈妈,可能是会更差劲吧。看这个电影和其他华裔拍亚洲家庭题材一样,除了展现我们痛苦的结构性问题,其他都非常的浅显。就是作为一个亚洲人,还是觉得是拍给地西方人看的电影。 那种“暖暖的”感觉,更像是西方人看东亚的那种“浅浅的”
55:25 00后的祖父母辈是60后,青春期失去了继续的读书机会,或者家庭几代积累的财富地位瞬间崩塌。代际之间传递给我的,是一种绵延的不安全感,以及对于不确定性的绝望感。翻译过来就是:渴望安稳。这也许是我们思维底层逻辑上真正的代沟所在。
阿弗罗颂:关系上体现的,则是无穷无尽的喜怒无常、条件性的爱。爱孩子,但如果孩子成为打破秩序的存在,那便是被深深厌恶的。
38:27 😧影后……最后几集简直是💩
pp_xyz
pp_xyz
2026.7.27
34:27 可能是……习得性无助?被圈在了过去的定式里,自己又要挣扎着养孩子和生存,所以不破定式,只是尽力让自己先别淹死,已经没力气管别的了,来什么就下意识地反应出来……
pp_xyz
pp_xyz
2026.7.27
06:04 🤣
pp_xyz
pp_xyz
2026.7.27
🎉
sheldor
sheldor
2026.7.28
Catherin Liu这个人感觉好tankie
疲惫阿花:哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
疲惫阿花:为啥!
5条回复
50:07 对!!!!!!!!
1:28:45 请问导演在哪里说的家庭渊源呀?
Ioioio
Ioioio
2026.7.28
来啦 这期也很棒
鱼丸子头
鱼丸子头
2026.7.27
52:18 艺术和历史对比的这个角度很有启发!
鱼丸子头
鱼丸子头
2026.7.27
1:22:13 结尾就是我不喜欢这部片的原因,如果主角是父亲,他只有被动的失权和妥协,看不出人物弧光。如果主角是nora,结局让她在另一位女性的安慰下选择宽恕。这样的故事有点太多了。
pp_xyz
pp_xyz
2026.7.27
1:04:15 太扎心了,老头能去跟🍵喝一壶
许愿re泡泡糖女孩,这部今年上影节个人最大惊喜